MS43.04: Francis Nicholson Papers
James Blair letter to [Archbishop of Canterbury], ca. October-November 1703

p1

A Memorial Concerning my troubles and Conduct in Virga
wth relacon to Govr Nicholson and ye Causes of my Coming for
England—

May itt please yor Grace

being sensible how dificult it is to find yor Grace soe free from
Company and other weighly business yt you can afford audience of yt
Length as to hear me tell ye storie of my troubles in virga and of
ye disappointmt of those good designes for ye Carieing on of wch Govr
Nicholson had soe much of yor Graces assistance towards ye procureing
him ye Governmt of yt Country I have chosen to sett down ye Cheife
of thoese things in a true and plaine Naritive in hopes your
Grace will find Some Leasure to preruse itt and will take those
Just Measures yt ye Circumstances of so Extraordinary a Case doe
require

ye Govrs
ingratitud
to me
I need not put yor Grace in mind how faithfully and diligently
I served G. N. in ye business of his promocon to ye Governmt.
while I was Last in Engld. it was at his Earnest importunity and
upon his Charge I undrtook yt voyage and negotiation; and
perform'd itt wth all ye Zeal for his Service, and as Little burthen to his
purss as was possible, I may say itt wthout vanity yt Saved him at
least many hundred of pounds he must have been out in any other
way of procureing such a governmt for tho he had given me a Lerr.
of Creditt and full power to Launch out Money either to courtiers
to procure him an interest, or to lawyers and sollicitrs to draw the
papers and Negotiate ye. business I spent him not one farthing in any
of those things: yor Grace and other good Bishopps favour supplying ye
place of a purchasd interest: and my own pains in drawing all papers
and Memorials and in attending ye proper times and opportunityes—
for pressing on ye affair supplying ye part of Lawyers and Sollicitrs
I Lost in yt year Service one year's Salary of my parish wch was as
good as one hundred pounds besides all other Losses and inconveniances
by Leaving my family and business and I fairly hazarded my own
ruin from Sr Edmd Andros by undrtaking ye affair, wch tho it was
managed wth soe many Losses hazards and difficultyes and attended wth.
ye wish'd for Success attain'd in soe hon.ble away, I Can't say I Ever had
soe much as thanks, farr less any other Considracons for that Service
he took an oppertunity not long after to tell me yt what I sai did
was for my own Ends, and there is No Subject he has insisted on
more frequantly than to upbraid me wth ingratitude, and some times
he makes his boast to others and has bragg'd of it to my selfe
yt he only made a tool of me—and both he and his frd C. Q.—
in their representacons for Engld have soe detracted from and
villified this service yt all ye part they assigne to me in it is
p2 that I honestly delivered ye Go.rs Let.rs, but
after some Experience of his temper I found
his behavior to me in point of gratitude was Not
singuler

and to ye
rest of
his old
frds
and that he served all his old frds
in virginia who had been true to him in ye worst
of times and had Enduered ye frowns of Sr E. A.'s
govermt upon his accot after ye very Same Manner
it being a true part of his Carecter yt he is very
kind to all those from whome he has any Expectacon
but ye most ingratefull man in ye world when ye
service is don: and he thinks has No more occacon
for them. Butt to goe on wth my story

his finding
fault wth
ye advice
of mode-
racon
Hee began his Govermt wth picking a quarrell wth. me
upon ye subject of Moderacon wch your Grace and severall
other of his frds had recomended to him in those very
Letrs. wch. I Carried him in together wth his Comission
for when he had perused ye Letrs. himselfe and shew'd
them to me he ask'd me what ye Devil they ment to
recomend Moderacon to him, and when I answer'd
that his frds were all of oppinion yt it was ye best
advice Cou'd be Given him, for said I they have seen
ye articles wch were Exhibited against yor Exccy from
Maryland and Judg'd yt all those ill things they accuse
you oft proceeded from yor passion and they know yt
in Virg.a as you have many frds soe Llikewise you have
diverse EEnemyes of Sr. E. A's party and therefore
they are affraid of yor resentmts.; I Can't but be of
theyr oppinion yt yor best way is to forgive and forgett
and to begin upon a New foot and to make yor Selfe
and Every boddy else: To this he reply'd very hotly God
I know better to govern virga. and Maryland then all ye
bishopps in England, if I had Not hamper'd them in
Maryland and kept them undr. I Shou'd Never have been
able to have Govern'd them Sr. said I don't pretent to undrstand
Maryld. but if know any thing of virga they are a Good
Natur'd tractable people as any in ye world and you
may doe what you will wth them by ye way of
p3 Civillity, but you will Never be able to manage them
in that way you speake oft by hampering and keeping
them undr. my Ld this was ye very day his Comission was
published, and at another Conference or two on ye same
subject in Less then six weeks time when I told him ye dangr
of Loosing assemblyes he seem'd to make Nothing of itt
and said he Cou'd find away to Govern ye Country wthout
assemblyes but yt way was a secret he thought not proppr
to Entrust to me how much soever he was bent upon it
for fear I shou'd give him some trouble in his New designs
he Carried ye argumt to yt height yt in great passion he
Comanded me never to Speake to him more in any Mat-
ters relating to ye Governmt. but to lett him alone and
Meddle wth my own business, wch I readily promised
perceiving yt he was strongly bent upon violent Meth-
ods in wch I was Consirnd resolved Not to be consirn'd

his harsh-
ness and
violent Methods
not owning
to passion
or amour
but designe
I have had frequent occasions since to reflect on this
discourse and to observe from itt a vulgar Error Concerning
Govr. Nicho. Imputing all ye violences of his Governmt.
both in Maryld and Virga to his passion or his amour
whereas it is Certaine they proceeded from designe and Int-
ention wch his passions were only made use of to Cover
and Conceale and I was ye more Confirm'd in this when
I Considred wt a quite deferent part he had acted while
he was Lt. G. of virga. and how mildly and Calmly I have
seen him behave himselfe towards strangers, and upon
severall other occasions when gentleness and Meekness would
serve a present turne, and yt ye Change began Not wth his
amour but wth his promotion to ye Govmt: in Cheife of that
Country and was Continued uniformely wthout interruption
Except on two severall occasions when his Interest (Not
his passion) obliged him for a little while to act an
another part. one was when he perswaded ye assembly
to advance 5 or 600 £. towards ye defraying ye Charge of
ye Imprisomt. and tryal of some pyrats that had been
taken in ye Country wch they allegd ought to have been
defry'd out of ye Spoile of ye Said pirats, ye other was p4 when he wanted addresses from ye assembly in his favr
to support his tottering interest and reputacon in Engld
upon both wch occasions (notwithstanding his passion and amour)
he did admirably act a good Natur'd Curtious governour; thô
both in ye interval between and all ye time before and after
these two occasions he has acted ye Quite Contrary; vizt. the
abitrary insolent and abusive part in psuance of a maine
designe he is a Carrying on wch I shall by and by discovr.

ye harsh
begining
of his
Governmt
Being thus laid asside from all opprtunity
of advice offering any [deleted] of advice I was Quickly
amazed wth ye strange stories I heard of his rudeness and
abusiveness mixt with terrible Curseing and Swearing to all
Sorts of people to yt degree yt No boddy went Near him but
in dread and terrour and yt in ye very Councills he was
soe furious Imperious and Menacing yt it was observed
and distinctly heard in houses a great way off and all
people seem'd to be struck wth his begining of his Governmt at
soe strange a rate of arbitraryness insolence and profaness
And indeed my Ld these fitts of passion (whether real or
Counterfeit) are soe habitual to him and are acted wth so
much rage and fury and doe soe Lively resemble those of a
Madman in his looks Gate and gesture yt ye greatest patience
is not able to Endure it nor no words can sufficiently describe
itt, one might as well pretend to describe an hurrycane to one
yt never saw it, as to think to discribe ye brutallity and savageness
of his passions and to make strangers sinsible what sort of things
they are: if they never were Eye and Eare wittnesses of them
such was Likewise his pride and Selfe-Conceite yt he thought itt
below him to Consult wth any person wtsoevr. and was altogether
uncapable of advice reasoning or Contradiction; I was utterly
at a loss wt Conjecture to make Concerning his designs, for itt
seem'd at first as if he had Laid down a resolution to dis-
oblige and abuse all mankind for he spoake in ye most Contem-
ptable terms of all ye best Gent wee had in ye Country treating
them wth ye vile Names of rogues raskals villains and Cowards &
swearing yt he valued them no more than ye dirt undr his feet
he did often hector bully and threaten to Cut their throats
and some times gave Challenges knowing ye station he was in
secured him yt they would Not be accepted, wch was ye occasion
Coll Parke yt his former tameness when in other Circumstances he was
Challeng'd and insulted by a Gent of that Country was often
remembred and Compared wth his hectoring and abusiveness p5 Leudeness all wch gave me ye Carecter of a bad man, and on ye
other hand recollecting his Charityes his Constancy in publicke
prayers his vigour and diligence in stiring about and driveing
on ye business of his Governmt. and his shewing some disting-
uishing respects at yt time to ye best men of our Cleargie tho
this is quite alter'd since) I was for a great while soe blinded
wth. my former good oppinion of him and phapps wthall
not a little biass'd by my own Interest and reputacon wch I
knew were firmely Link't wth his yt for a great while after
he was detected by others yt were Near wittnesses of his Life &
Conversation I inclin'd to ye Charitable side had still good hope
of him defended him on all occasions and took him to be
a good man at bottome only I thought he had been much
spoil'd in Maryld. his Temper Sowr'd there soe finding them
a people much wrought upon by terrour threatening yt
he had Laid it down as an unhappy Maxim to himselfe
yt ye way of terrour was ye best way to Manage those Countryes
and I Confess at that time I had observed Nothing of dishonesty.
nor of any down right imorallity more then I was willing
to ascribe partly to his great passion and ptly to his false
Maxims of pollicie and ptly to humane Frailty and In-
firmity

how my
Eyes were
oppen'd
by his
Leudness
But while I was in this uncertainty of oppinion abt him
it pleased God to open my Eyes after a very strange and un-
expected Manner ye pticulars whereof are Not so proper to be
put in writing, in Genll it was a scene of one of ye vilest &
grossest Sorts of Leudness described to me wth horror by such
Certaine proofe and Conviction yt I Could no way answer Nor
resist it had almost broke my heart wth Sorry and made
strange Impressions upon me Soe as to worke in me a total
alteracon of my former oppinion of yt. Gent. for I Confess my
Lord I Could Never Induce my selfe after this to have any
good thoughts of his sincerity in religion but Look't upon
him from yt hour as a great Monster of Imorality and my
oppinion recd daily Conformacon by ye new discoveries I made
upon Inquirie into ye ptiulers of his Life and Conversation.
I found great observacons had been made in Many Gent houses
in ye Country of his Strang leudness to a degree of Impudence
and Brutality beyond that of most other men for Not Contented
wth such vitious Companions as himselfe and Such men Cou'd
Easily find in all Countryes he made many base attempts upon
p6 persons of honor. and virtue and those wth such a-
bundance of rudeness and violence as looked more
Like a designe of perpetrating a rape than obtaining
a Consent

Enmity
&
revenge
Then for Mallice and revenge it is not Easily
Credible what abundance of Satisfacon he tooke in
itt how diligently he psu'd itt to ye utter ruin Not only
of ye pties whome he tooke to be his adversaries but
of all their acquaintance friends and relacons I Cou'd
give your Grace several Instances of this and of his
Cruelty and bloody Mindedness for he has talkd to me
for many Mos. together of Nothing else but designs to
Cutt ye. throats of several pticuler psons and in ye whole
story of his amours wch then brakeout he gave such Num-
erous, Instances of fury Jelosie and revenge &c threating
&c wth many other Extravagant things of this Nature that
I realy Came at last to Considr him as a Man of ye
blackest Soul and Conscience yt I had Ever known in
my life for I found when once he had affronted
any man to yt height as to recon him his Enemy
he then thought himselfe absolved from all rules
of Justice honor and honesty to such a pson to yt
degree yt if he Cou'd ruin him in his good Name by
ye falsest and grossest lyes and Callumnies or in his
Estate by ye basest tricks lawsuits and Circumventons
or in his frds by all the seeds of Enmity and discord
yt Could possibly be Sown or in his Corrispondence
by intercepting and breaking open his Letrs or in
any thing else wherein he Could work his ruin
or prejudice he stuck at nothing for Compassing
his revenge and in Contriveing ye wayes and means
thereof I found yt of all other things he was by
much ye most inventive and Ingenious

Memorial
agst
Govr Nicholson